The Why Of The Boycott On Israel.

The economic victories of the Boycott Divestment Sanction (BDS)*  movement against Israel over the past decade cannot even be counted on the fingers of one hand. There have not been any.

UK/Israel trade is at a record high, Turkey/Israel trade is booming, as is that between Israel/Indian. The Israelis are almost having to beat the Chinese off with a stick such is Beijing’s keenness to become more involved with one of the worlds key tech nations.

No foreign investment has left Israel; no corporation abroad has severed ties. The centers of learning around the world have not cut links, nor have they divested themselves of shares in Israeli companies.

Further, unless you are part of the 0.1% of the world, which is Jewish, Israeli, or a BDS member, you may never have heard of BDS. So, what’s the big deal?

The confusion over a statement of an Orange executive about wanting to cut ties,  and the UK’s National Union of Student’s decision to support BDS, dominated news in Israel last week. At this week’s Herzliya Security Conference it was the focus of many speeches and earnest debate.

The reason is that, here, most people understand clearly what many well meaning, if naive, BDS supporters in the UK do not – that BDS is not about economics, and the economic well being of Palestinians, it is about the destruction of Israel.

Britain’s former Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks made the point well in Herzliya saying that BDS was about “Trying to make Israel friendless, so it will be defenceless”.

The movement is led by people who understand that failing to achieve a boycott is not failure.  The intention is to chip away at the legitimacy of Israel, to exhaust the academics, intellectuals, and politicians who will defend the country and frighten the less robust among them.  They also intend the coming generations of opinion formers and politicians to have been thoroughly indoctrinated by their dissembling arguments.

Occasionally the mask slips, Marghan Barghouti, a leading Palestinian BDS figure is on record as saying “If the occupation ends, would that end our call for BDS? No it wouldn’t”.

That is why Prime Minister Netanyahu bothered to react to the pinprick of the NUS decision last week. That was a mistake which will have had the students high fiving each other, but it showed how much the Israelis get the wider agenda to portray them as a people to be shunned.

The former director general of Strategic Affairs, Brig Gen (Rtd) Yossi Kuperwasser, told the W&Y “He did it to turn it into a major event in the press in Israel… but that hysteria is a reflection of a wider agenda to portray Israelis as a people unworthy of normal social discourse and trade.”

Ofer Shelachi, a member of the Knesset in the centrist Yesh Atid party, hardly a friend of the settlers, told the W&Y ‘You don’t have to be right wing to see that BDS is not just about occupation, it’s also about anti-semitism”.

Whether or not you agree with that, it is necessary to look at the BDS in two ways – as a failure insofar as the Israeli economy has doubled in size in the period BDS has been in operation, but at the same time, as a success when you see the effect of the propaganda campaign on a thousand university campuses, among thousands of people, many who will go on to become opinion formers. It is a decades long strategy.

 

*The BDS movement denies being anti-Semitic and says it “calls for a campaign of boycotts, divestment and sanctions against Israel until it complies with international law and Palestinian rights.”

From an article originally published in the UK’s Jewish Chronicle

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

8 Comments on "The Why Of The Boycott On Israel."

  1. If it says made in Israel I put it back on the shelf. I try and persuade my friends to do the same (with different levels of success) Big corporations didn’t leave South Africa until there was a tipping point, that took 25 years, we are 10 years into the BDS campaign and Netanyahu is already flailing around like a beached whale.

    The BDS campaign will succeed, it is only a matter of time, the Academics are already leaving Israel, companies are already stopping sharing tech with Israel as they research and develop new technology to sell, as they do not want it boycotted. Orange will leave Israel, when the cost of staying outweighs the profit being lost. People are already avoiding doing business, in fact the threats levelled at Orange by Israeli government and businesses makes investment in Israel less likely.

    Yet we are told time and again that BDS isn’t working, it is a busted flush. Not from where I am sat it isn’t, it is growing, and the Israeli establishment are panicking, which to be honest is fun to watch

    • A few significant differences between apartheid South Africa and democratic Israel:

      – In SA no blacks in the judiciary, while in Israel the President of the Supreme Court is an Arab.

      – In SA, blacks not allowed to vote while in Israel the United Arab List elected 13 out of 120 MPs in the Knesset.

      – Israel was given to the Jews by God – see for examples Psalms 2 and 83 for why BDS will fail.

  2. Mahatmacoatmabag | 28th June 2015 at 12:42 pm | Reply

    BDS acts as a subsidiary to the Palestinian Authority. BDS is not listed anywhere as neither an independent organization, nor does it even hold or own a bank account, anywhere in the world. The PLO has never stopped promoting the Arab boycott of Israel, even though one of the explicit clauses of the “declaration of principles” in the Oslo Accords, was that the PLO would no longer support the Arab League boycott of Israel. Why? What has escaped public attention is that the PLO never ratified the “declaration of principles,” the most fundamental document of the Israel-Palestinian Oslo accord, nor did the PLO ever cancel its charter to destroy Israel, which was another major clause in that accord.

    BDS activists, mostly from campuses in the West, now make timely visits to the PA in Ramallah, where cash is allocated for an untold number of BDS activists to take cash home with them for the BDS activities. Why should funds from Western tax payers be used by the PA and their cohorts? Cut the funding to the PA and UNWRA, and the BDS spigot will dry up very quickly.

  3. Reply to Chris (12/6)….

    If I see ‘Made in Israel’ I buy two.

    Which, to be honest, is fun to do.

  4. I bought a plastic deck storage box from Keter. It was masterfully designed and made proudly in Israel. I bought two because I needed two. My friends saw it and I told them I got it at Lowes they bought one too. Nobody has the skill and design capabilities like Israel. BDS is a failed idea. The idiots should stop using Intel computer chips designed in Israel and oops also their camera phone et etc.

  5. AD – he’s getting paid folks. Don’t waste your time.

Leave a comment

favorites.png
Comments are moderated before they are published. Please consider if you're contributing to the discussion before you post. Abuse and general negativity will not be allowed to appear on the site. This might be the Internet but let's try to keep things civil.
 

Your email address will not be published.


*


*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.