Invalid or Broken rss link.

This week British Trade Minister, Mark Price, was in the Swiss capital talking trade and immigration. On Monday it’s the turn of the EU Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker and during his visit we may see hints of the EU’s approach to negotiating Brexit with London.TM

While Mr Price wanted to know more about how the Swiss were managing their own EU deal with Brussels in order to learn lessons for the future EU/UK deal, Mr. Juncker will want to make a stand on the free movement of labour in part as a warning to the British not to expect compromise on the issue.

Switzerland has more than 100 bilateral agreements with the EU and through them has access to the European Single Market despite not being a member. The major quid pro quo is that Switzerland must accept EU workers. However, this position has been complicated by the February 2014 referendum vote to limit immigration which must be implemented by February 2017.

Something has to give. The parliament in Bern is hammering out legislation to make it law that Swiss citizens be given priority for jobs, but immigration will still be allowed. The assumption is that fewer people will come to the country if jobs are harder to find.

Depending on the wording, and the interpretation of it in Brussels, this might fly, but Mr. Juncker may still bristle against it. What probably would not fly is the modified legislation the Swiss Christian Democratic People’s Party wants – to prioritize jobs for Swiss people but also to impose fixed quotas on immigration from EU countries.

Juncker will not buy that, and he will be supported by many EU countries. He knows if he gives in on that issue in Switzerland, the precedent will be set for the British to follow suit.

In the event that both countries got what Brussels would consider a ‘soft deal’ it would encourage other EU members to consider quitting the union under similar agreements.

So, the Swiss deal is well worth watching for its implications on which model of relationship with the EU the UK thinks it should use as a template while simultaneously shaping a one off agreement.

Mr. Juncker’s wants ‘ever closer union’ (Ecu), not a free trade zone, and is likely to play hardball with both Bern and London. However, the Ecu supporters risk actually breaking the Union if they rush to achieve their aim. The winds of resistance are blowing hard against them at both political party level in Europe and in public opinion.

It’s a delicate balancing act, but the instincts of the Ecus will be to charge ahead and simultaneously send signals that leaving the union would be painful. It’s going to be a bruising debate.

Back in Britain the pro Brexit lobby is already growing impatient with Prime Minister May’s quiet deliberations on a timetable to leave. However, that is to mistake silence for indecision. There are many moving parts to moving out of the EU as the Swiss negotiations show us. She’s waiting to see the next move before making her own.


5 Comments on "The UK And The EU Feel The Bern."

  1. Negotiations ought to be fairly simple from our perspective. We offer trading under WTO rules unless the member states wish to have a different relationship. If they do wish for a closer trading relationship then we will listen but freedom of movement and the primacy of the UK legal system are red lines. Give them something they don’t expect, put the ball in their court and let them squabble with each other rather than the other way round. Do I think it will happen, nope, our politicians are too weak unfortunately and we have what could be best described as a fifth column operating within the country trying to foul up our exit. The recent contempt for Irelands right to set it’s own tax rates and the thinly veiled threats to Hungary are just more evidence (if it were needed) of what the EU really is and where it is heading. The greater the distance between them and us the better, regardless of the economic impact.

  2. Up here in Skintland, the SNP Executive (its not a Parliament by the way) put it that the status quo of remaining in the EU as the only way forward. Since the vote, things have changed-and will continue to do. TM would be mad to rush in-its a big world out there-and now we have the Chinese back on board :-), things will move on.

  3. This morning the Brexiteers have found another fly in their ointment. Speaking on behalf of the Visegrad Group Slovakian PM Robert Fico said that any attempt to limit the right of EU citizens to work in the UK would result in them voting against any Brexit deal.

    However, there is now some disagreement as to whether Mr Fico speaks on behalf of the whole group.

  4. How is that a fly in the ointment?. Most Brexiteers favour a clean break from Europe not some EU lite deal. As for the Visegrad nations, their hypocrisy is startling. Easily the most racist countries in the EU they try anything to stop foreigners settling in their countries while joyfully exporting their youngsters to control unemployement. They complained about how Brexit would hurt them after offering Cameron nothing in negotiations that may have tipped the result of the referendum. While they protested about Soviet control during the Cold war they are now clearly happy to accept becoming satellites of a German run federated state.

  5. Don#t worry Rob.I am no fan of Orban and Fico. Viktor Orban in particular protests loudly about the EU yet is quite happy to accept their money so that he can build his latest football stadium.

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated before they are published. Please consider if you're contributing to the discussion before you post. Abuse and general negativity will not be allowed to appear on the site. This might be the Internet but let's try to keep things civil.

Your email address will not be published.



This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.